/*++ Copyright (c) 2015 Microsoft Corporation Module Name: nlqsat.cpp Abstract: Quantifier Satisfiability Solver for nlsat Author: Nikolaj Bjorner (nbjorner) 2015-10-17 Revision History: --*/ #include "util/uint_set.h" #include "util/scoped_ptr_vector.h" #include "ast/expr2var.h" #include "ast/ast_util.h" #include "ast/rewriter/expr_safe_replace.h" #include "ast/ast_pp.h" #include "ast/for_each_expr.h" #include "ast/rewriter/rewriter.h" #include "ast/rewriter/th_rewriter.h" #include "ast/rewriter/rewriter_def.h" #include "ast/rewriter/quant_hoist.h" #include "qe/nlqsat.h" #include "qe/qsat.h" #include "nlsat/nlsat_solver.h" #include "nlsat/nlsat_explain.h" #include "nlsat/nlsat_assignment.h" #include "nlsat/tactic/goal2nlsat.h" #include "tactic/core/tseitin_cnf_tactic.h" namespace qe { enum qsat_mode_t { qsat_t, elim_t }; class nlqsat : public tactic { typedef unsigned_vector assumption_vector; typedef nlsat::scoped_literal_vector clause; struct stats { unsigned m_num_rounds; stats() { reset(); } void reset() { memset(this, 0, sizeof(*this)); } }; struct solver_state { ast_manager& m; params_ref m_params; nlsat::solver m_solver; nlsat::literal m_is_true; nlsat::assignment m_rmodel; svector m_bmodel; nlsat::assignment m_rmodel0; svector m_bmodel0; bool m_valid_model; vector m_bound_rvars; vector > m_bound_bvars; scoped_ptr_vector m_preds; svector m_rvar2level; u_map m_bvar2level; expr2var m_a2b, m_t2x; u_map m_b2a, m_x2t; nlsat::literal_vector m_assumptions; nlsat::literal_vector m_asms; nlsat::literal_vector m_cached_asms; unsigned_vector m_cached_asms_lim; u_map m_asm2fml; solver_state(ast_manager& m, params_ref const& p): m(m), m_params(p), m_solver(m.limit(), p, true), m_rmodel(m_solver.am()), m_rmodel0(m_solver.am()), m_valid_model(false), m_a2b(m), m_t2x(m) {} void g2s(goal const& g) { goal2nlsat gs; gs(g, m_params, m_solver, m_a2b, m_t2x); } void init_expr2var(vector const& qvars) { for (app_ref_vector const& qvs : qvars) { init_expr2var(qvs); } } void init_expr2var(app_ref_vector const& qvars) { for (app* v : qvars) { if (m.is_bool(v)) { nlsat::bool_var b = m_solver.mk_bool_var(); m_solver.inc_ref(b); m_a2b.insert(v, b); } else { // TODO: assert it is of type Real. m_t2x.insert(v, m_solver.mk_var(false)); } } } void init_var2expr() { for (auto const& kv : m_t2x) { m_x2t.insert(kv.m_value, kv.m_key); } for (auto const& kv : m_a2b) { m_b2a.insert(kv.m_value, kv.m_key); } } void save_model(bool is_exists) { svector bvars; for (auto const& kv : m_bvar2level) { bvars.push_back(kv.m_key); } m_solver.get_rvalues(m_rmodel); m_solver.get_bvalues(bvars, m_bmodel); m_valid_model = true; if (is_exists) { m_rmodel0.copy(m_rmodel); m_bmodel0.reset(); m_bmodel0.append(m_bmodel); } } void unsave_model() { SASSERT(m_valid_model); m_solver.set_rvalues(m_rmodel); m_solver.set_bvalues(m_bmodel); } void clear_model() { m_valid_model = false; m_rmodel.reset(); m_bmodel.reset(); m_solver.set_rvalues(m_rmodel); } void add_assumption_literal(clause& clause, expr* fml) { nlsat::bool_var b = m_solver.mk_bool_var(); clause.push_back(nlsat::literal(b, true)); m_assumptions.push_back(nlsat::literal(b, false)); m_solver.inc_ref(b); m_asm2fml.insert(b, fml); m_bvar2level.insert(b, max_level()); } expr_ref clause2fml(nlsat::scoped_literal_vector const& clause) { expr_ref_vector fmls(m); expr_ref fml(m); expr* t; nlsat2goal n2g(m); for (nlsat::literal l : clause) { if (m_asm2fml.find(l.var(), t)) { fml = t; if (l.sign()) { fml = push_not(fml); } SASSERT(l.sign()); fmls.push_back(fml); } else { fmls.push_back(n2g(m_solver, m_b2a, m_x2t, l)); } } fml = mk_or(fmls); return fml; } void add_literal(nlsat::literal_vector& lits, nlsat::literal l) { lbool r = m_solver.value(l); switch (r) { case l_true: lits.push_back(l); break; case l_false: lits.push_back(~l); break; default: lits.push_back(l); break; } } void display(std::ostream& out) { out << "level " << level() << "\n"; display_preds(out); display_assumptions(out); m_solver.display(out << "solver:\n"); } void display_assumptions(std::ostream& out) { m_solver.display(out << "assumptions: ", m_asms.size(), m_asms.c_ptr()); out << "\n"; } void display_preds(std::ostream& out) { for (unsigned i = 0; i < m_preds.size(); ++i) { m_solver.display(out << i << ": ", m_preds[i]->size(), m_preds[i]->c_ptr()); out << "\n"; } } unsigned level() const { return m_cached_asms_lim.size(); } void reset() { m_asms.reset(); m_cached_asms.reset(); m_cached_asms_lim.reset(); m_is_true = nlsat::null_literal; m_rmodel.reset(); m_valid_model = false; m_bound_rvars.reset(); m_bound_bvars.reset(); m_preds.reset(); for (auto const& kv : m_bvar2level) { m_solver.dec_ref(kv.m_key); } m_rvar2level.reset(); m_bvar2level.reset(); m_t2x.reset(); m_a2b.reset(); m_b2a.reset(); m_x2t.reset(); m_assumptions.reset(); m_asm2fml.reset(); } }; ast_manager& m; solver_state s; qsat_mode_t m_mode; params_ref m_params; tactic_ref m_nftactic; stats m_stats; statistics m_st; obj_hashtable m_free_vars; obj_hashtable m_aux_vars; expr_ref_vector m_answer; expr_safe_replace m_answer_simplify; expr_ref_vector m_trail; lbool check_sat() { while (true) { ++m_stats.m_num_rounds; check_cancel(); init_assumptions(); lbool res = s.m_solver.check(s.m_asms); TRACE("qe", s.display(tout << res << "\n"); ); switch (res) { case l_true: s.save_model(is_exists(level())); push(); break; case l_false: if (0 == level()) return l_false; if (1 == level() && m_mode == qsat_t) return l_true; project(); break; case l_undef: return res; } } return l_undef; } void init_assumptions() { unsigned lvl = level(); s.m_asms.reset(); s.m_asms.push_back(is_exists()?s.m_is_true:~s.m_is_true); s.m_asms.append(s.m_assumptions); TRACE("qe", tout << "model valid: " << s.m_valid_model << " level: " << lvl << " "; s.display_assumptions(tout); s.m_solver.display(tout);); if (!s.m_valid_model) { s.m_asms.append(s.m_cached_asms); return; } s.unsave_model(); if (lvl == 0) { SASSERT(s.m_cached_asms.empty()); return; } if (lvl <= s.m_preds.size()) { for (unsigned j = 0; j < s.m_preds[lvl - 1]->size(); ++j) { s.add_literal(s.m_cached_asms, (*s.m_preds[lvl - 1])[j]); } } s.m_asms.append(s.m_cached_asms); for (unsigned i = lvl + 1; i < s.m_preds.size(); i += 2) { for (unsigned j = 0; j < s.m_preds[i]->size(); ++j) { nlsat::literal l = (*s.m_preds[i])[j]; max_level lv = s.m_bvar2level.find(l.var()); bool use = (lv.m_fa == i && (lv.m_ex == UINT_MAX || lv.m_ex < lvl)) || (lv.m_ex == i && (lv.m_fa == UINT_MAX || lv.m_fa < lvl)); if (use) { s.add_literal(s.m_asms, l); } } } TRACE("qe", s.display(tout); tout << "assumptions\n"; for (nlsat::literal a : s.m_asms) { s.m_solver.display(tout, a) << "\n"; }); s.save_model(is_exists(level())); } template void insert_set(S& set, T const& vec) { for (auto const& v : vec) { set.insert(v); } } void mbp(unsigned level, nlsat::scoped_literal_vector& result) { nlsat::var_vector vars; uint_set fvars; extract_vars(level, vars, fvars); mbp(vars, fvars, result); } void extract_vars(unsigned level, nlsat::var_vector& vars, uint_set& fvars) { for (unsigned i = 0; i < s.m_bound_rvars.size(); ++i) { if (i < level) { insert_set(fvars, s.m_bound_bvars[i]); } else { vars.append(s.m_bound_rvars[i]); } } } void display_project(std::ostream& out, nlsat::var v, nlsat::scoped_literal_vector const& r1, nlsat::scoped_literal_vector const& r2) { for (auto const& kv : s.m_x2t) { out << "(declare-const x" << kv.m_key << " Real)\n"; } s.m_solver.display(out << "(assert (not (exists ((", v) << " Real)) \n"; s.m_solver.display_smt2(out << "(and ", r1.size(), r1.c_ptr()) << "))))\n"; s.m_solver.display_smt2(out << "(assert (and ", r2.size(), r2.c_ptr()); out << "))\n"; out << "(check-sat)\n(reset)\n"; } void mbp(nlsat::var_vector const& vars, uint_set const& fvars, clause& result) { // // Also project auxiliary variables from clausification. // s.unsave_model(); nlsat::explain& ex = s.m_solver.get_explain(); nlsat::scoped_literal_vector new_result(s.m_solver); result.reset(); // project quantified Boolean variables. for (nlsat::literal lit : s.m_asms) { if (!s.m_b2a.contains(lit.var()) || fvars.contains(lit.var())) { result.push_back(lit); } } TRACE("qe", s.m_solver.display(tout, result.size(), result.c_ptr()); tout << "\n";); // project quantified real variables. // They are sorted by size, so we project the largest variables first to avoid // renaming variables. for (unsigned i = vars.size(); i-- > 0;) { new_result.reset(); ex.project(vars[i], result.size(), result.c_ptr(), new_result); TRACE("qe", display_project(tout, vars[i], result, new_result);); TRACE("qe", display_project(std::cout, vars[i], result, new_result);); result.swap(new_result); } negate_clause(result); } void negate_clause(clause& result) { for (unsigned i = 0; i < result.size(); ++i) { result.set(i, ~result[i]); } } unsigned level() const { return s.level(); } void enforce_parity(clause& cl) { cl.push_back(is_exists()?~s.m_is_true:s.m_is_true); } void add_clause(clause& cl) { if (cl.empty()) { cl.push_back(~s.m_solver.mk_true()); } SASSERT(!cl.empty()); nlsat::literal_vector lits(cl.size(), cl.c_ptr()); s.m_solver.mk_clause(lits.size(), lits.c_ptr()); } max_level get_level(clause const& cl) { return get_level(cl.size(), cl.c_ptr()); } max_level get_level(unsigned n, nlsat::literal const* ls) { max_level level; for (unsigned i = 0; i < n; ++i) { level.merge(get_level(ls[i])); } return level; } max_level get_level(nlsat::literal l) { max_level level; if (s.m_bvar2level.find(l.var(), level)) { return level; } nlsat::var_vector vs; s.m_solver.vars(l, vs); TRACE("qe", s.m_solver.display(tout << vs << " ", l) << "\n";); for (unsigned v : vs) { level.merge(s.m_rvar2level[v]); } set_level(l.var(), level); return level; } void set_level(nlsat::bool_var v, max_level const& level) { unsigned k = level.max(); while (s.m_preds.size() <= k) { s.m_preds.push_back(alloc(nlsat::scoped_literal_vector, s.m_solver)); } nlsat::literal l(v, false); s.m_preds[k]->push_back(l); s.m_solver.inc_ref(v); s.m_bvar2level.insert(v, level); TRACE("qe", s.m_solver.display(tout, l); tout << ": " << level << "\n";); } void project() { TRACE("qe", s.display_assumptions(tout);); if (!s.m_valid_model) { pop(1); return; } if (m_mode == elim_t) { project_qe(); return; } SASSERT(level() >= 2); unsigned num_scopes; clause cl(s.m_solver); mbp(level()-1, cl); max_level clevel = get_level(cl); enforce_parity(cl); add_clause(cl); if (clevel.max() == UINT_MAX) { num_scopes = 2*(level()/2); } else { SASSERT(clevel.max() + 2 <= level()); num_scopes = level() - clevel.max(); SASSERT(num_scopes >= 2); } TRACE("qe", tout << "backtrack: " << num_scopes << "\n";); pop(num_scopes); } void project_qe() { SASSERT(level() >= 1 && m_mode == elim_t && s.m_valid_model); clause cl(s.m_solver); mbp(std::max(1u, level()-1), cl); expr_ref fml = s.clause2fml(cl); TRACE("qe", tout << level() << ": " << fml << "\n";); max_level clevel = get_level(cl); if (level() == 1 || clevel.max() == 0) { add_assumption_literal(cl, fml); } else { enforce_parity(cl); } add_clause(cl); if (level() == 1) { // is_forall() && clevel.max() == 0 add_to_answer(fml); } if (level() == 1) { pop(1); } else { pop(2); } } void add_to_answer(expr_ref& fml) { m_answer_simplify(fml); expr* e; if (m.is_not(fml, e)) { m_answer_simplify.insert(e, m.mk_false()); } else { m_answer_simplify.insert(fml, m.mk_true()); } m_answer.push_back(fml); } void add_assumption_literal(clause& clause, expr* fml) { s.add_assumption_literal(clause, fml); m_trail.push_back(fml); } bool is_exists() const { return is_exists(level()); } bool is_forall() const { return is_forall(level()); } bool is_exists(unsigned level) const { return (level % 2) == 0; } bool is_forall(unsigned level) const { return is_exists(level+1); } void check_cancel() { } struct div { expr_ref num, den; app_ref name; div(ast_manager& m, expr* n, expr* d, app* nm): num(n, m), den(d, m), name(nm, m) {} }; class div_rewriter_cfg : public default_rewriter_cfg { ast_manager& m; arith_util a; expr_ref m_zero; vector
m_divs; public: div_rewriter_cfg(nlqsat& s): m(s.m), a(s.m), m_zero(a.mk_real(0), m) {} ~div_rewriter_cfg() {} br_status reduce_app(func_decl* f, unsigned sz, expr* const* args, expr_ref& result, proof_ref& pr) { rational r(1); if (is_decl_of(f, a.get_family_id(), OP_DIV) && sz == 2 && (!a.is_numeral(args[1], r) || r.is_zero()) && is_ground(args[0]) && is_ground(args[1])) { result = m.mk_fresh_const("div", a.mk_real()); m_divs.push_back(div(m, args[0], args[1], to_app(result))); return BR_DONE; } return BR_FAILED; } vector
const& divs() const { return m_divs; } }; //template class rewriter_tpl; class div_rewriter_star : public rewriter_tpl { div_rewriter_cfg m_cfg; public: div_rewriter_star(nlqsat& s): rewriter_tpl(s.m, false, m_cfg), m_cfg(s) {} vector
const& divs() const { return m_cfg.divs(); } }; class is_pure_proc { nlqsat& s; arith_util a; bool m_has_divs; public: is_pure_proc(nlqsat& s): s(s), a(s.m), m_has_divs(false) {} void operator()(::var * n) { if (!a.is_real(n) && !s.m.is_bool(n)) { throw tactic_exception("not NRA"); } } void operator()(app * n) { if (n->get_family_id() == s.m.get_basic_family_id()) { return; } if (is_uninterp_const(n) && (a.is_real(n) || s.m.is_bool(n))) { return; } if (a.is_mul(n) || a.is_add(n) || a.is_sub(n) || a.is_uminus(n) || a.is_numeral(n) || a.is_le(n) || a.is_ge(n) || a.is_lt(n) || a.is_gt(n)) { return; } expr* n1, *n2; rational r; if (a.is_div(n, n1, n2) && a.is_numeral(n2, r) && !r.is_zero()) { return; } if (a.is_power(n, n1, n2) && a.is_numeral(n2, r) && r.is_unsigned()) { return; } if (a.is_div(n) && s.m_mode == qsat_t) { m_has_divs = true; return; } TRACE("qe", tout << "not NRA: " << mk_pp(n, s.m) << "\n";); throw tactic_exception("not NRA"); } void operator()(quantifier * n) {} bool has_divs() const { return m_has_divs; } }; /* Ackermanize division For each p/q: q != 0 => div_pq*q = p For each p/q, p'/q' p = p', q = q' => div_pq = div_pq' */ void ackermanize_div(expr_ref& fml, expr_ref_vector& paxioms) { is_pure_proc is_pure(*this); { expr_fast_mark1 visited; quick_for_each_expr(is_pure, visited, fml); } if (is_pure.has_divs()) { arith_util arith(m); proof_ref pr(m); div_rewriter_star rw(*this); rw(fml, fml, pr); vector
const& divs = rw.divs(); for (unsigned i = 0; i < divs.size(); ++i) { expr_ref den_is0(m.mk_eq(divs[i].den, arith.mk_real(0)), m); paxioms.push_back(m.mk_or(den_is0, m.mk_eq(divs[i].num, arith.mk_mul(divs[i].den, divs[i].name)))); for (unsigned j = i + 1; j < divs.size(); ++j) { paxioms.push_back(m.mk_or(m.mk_not(m.mk_eq(divs[i].den, divs[j].den)), m.mk_not(m.mk_eq(divs[i].num, divs[j].num)), m.mk_eq(divs[i].name, divs[j].name))); } } } } void reset() override { s.reset(); m_st.reset(); s.m_solver.collect_statistics(m_st); m_free_vars.reset(); m_aux_vars.reset(); m_answer.reset(); m_answer_simplify.reset(); m_trail.reset(); } void push() { s.m_cached_asms_lim.push_back(s.m_cached_asms.size()); } void pop(unsigned num_scopes) { s.clear_model(); unsigned new_level = level() - num_scopes; s.m_cached_asms.shrink(s.m_cached_asms_lim[new_level]); s.m_cached_asms_lim.shrink(new_level); } // expr -> nlsat::solver bool hoist(expr_ref& fml) { expr_ref_vector paxioms(m); ackermanize_div(fml, paxioms); quantifier_hoister hoist(m); vector qvars; app_ref_vector vars(m); bool is_forall = false; pred_abs abs(m); expr_ref fml_a(m.mk_and(fml, mk_and(paxioms)), m); abs.get_free_vars(fml_a, vars); insert_set(m_free_vars, vars); qvars.push_back(vars); vars.reset(); if (m_mode == elim_t) { is_forall = true; hoist.pull_quantifier(is_forall, fml, vars); qvars.push_back(vars); } else { hoist.pull_quantifier(is_forall, fml, vars); qvars.back().append(vars); } do { is_forall = !is_forall; vars.reset(); hoist.pull_quantifier(is_forall, fml, vars); qvars.push_back(vars); } while (!vars.empty()); SASSERT(qvars.size() >= 2); SASSERT(qvars.back().empty()); s.init_expr2var(qvars); expr_ref is_true(m), fml1(m), fml2(m); is_true = m.mk_fresh_const("is_true", m.mk_bool_sort()); fml = m.mk_iff(is_true, fml); goal_ref g = alloc(goal, m); g->assert_expr(fml); for (expr* f : paxioms) { g->assert_expr(f); } expr_dependency_ref core(m); goal_ref_buffer result; (*m_nftactic)(g, result); SASSERT(result.size() == 1); TRACE("qe", result[0]->display(tout);); s.g2s(*result[0]); // insert variables and their levels. for (unsigned i = 0; i < qvars.size(); ++i) { s.m_bound_bvars.push_back(svector()); s.m_bound_rvars.push_back(nlsat::var_vector()); max_level lvl; if (is_exists(i)) lvl.m_ex = i; else lvl.m_fa = i; for (app* v : qvars[i]) { if (s.m_a2b.is_var(v)) { SASSERT(m.is_bool(v)); nlsat::bool_var b = s.m_a2b.to_var(v); TRACE("qe", tout << mk_pp(v, m) << " |-> b" << b << "\n";); s.m_bound_bvars.back().push_back(b); set_level(b, lvl); } else if (s.m_t2x.is_var(v)) { nlsat::var w = s.m_t2x.to_var(v); TRACE("qe", tout << mk_pp(v, m) << " |-> x" << w << "\n";); s.m_bound_rvars.back().push_back(w); s.m_rvar2level.setx(w, lvl, max_level()); } else { TRACE("qe", tout << mk_pp(v, m) << " not found\n";); } } } s.init_var2expr(); s.m_is_true = nlsat::literal(s.m_a2b.to_var(is_true), false); // insert literals from arithmetical sub-formulas nlsat::atom_vector const& atoms = s.m_solver.get_atoms(); TRACE("qe", s.m_solver.display(tout);); for (unsigned i = 0; i < atoms.size(); ++i) { if (atoms[i]) { get_level(nlsat::literal(i, false)); } } TRACE("qe", tout << fml << "\n";); return true; } // Return false if nlsat assigned noninteger value to an integer variable. // [copied from nlsat_tactic.cpp] bool mk_model(model_converter_ref & mc) { bool ok = true; model_ref md = alloc(model, m); arith_util util(m); for (auto const& kv : s.m_t2x) { nlsat::var x = kv.m_value; expr * t = kv.m_key; if (!is_uninterp_const(t) || !m_free_vars.contains(t) || m_aux_vars.contains(t)) continue; expr * v; try { v = util.mk_numeral(s.m_rmodel0.value(x), util.is_int(t)); } catch (z3_error & ex) { throw ex; } catch (z3_exception &) { v = util.mk_to_int(util.mk_numeral(s.m_rmodel0.value(x), false)); ok = false; } md->register_decl(to_app(t)->get_decl(), v); } for (auto const& kv : s.m_a2b) { expr * a = kv.m_key; nlsat::bool_var b = kv.m_value; if (a == nullptr || !is_uninterp_const(a) || b == s.m_is_true.var() || !m_free_vars.contains(a) || m_aux_vars.contains(a)) continue; lbool val = s.m_bmodel0.get(b, l_undef); if (val == l_undef) continue; // don't care md->register_decl(to_app(a)->get_decl(), val == l_true ? m.mk_true() : m.mk_false()); } mc = model2model_converter(md.get()); return ok; } public: nlqsat(ast_manager& m, qsat_mode_t mode, params_ref const& p): m(m), s(m, p), m_mode(mode), m_params(p), m_nftactic(nullptr), m_answer(m), m_answer_simplify(m), m_trail(m) { s.m_solver.get_explain().set_signed_project(true); m_nftactic = mk_tseitin_cnf_tactic(m); } ~nlqsat() override { } void updt_params(params_ref const & p) override { params_ref p2(p); p2.set_bool("factor", false); s.m_solver.updt_params(p2); } void collect_param_descrs(param_descrs & r) override { } void operator()(/* in */ goal_ref const & in, /* out */ goal_ref_buffer & result) override { tactic_report report("nlqsat-tactic", *in); ptr_vector fmls; expr_ref fml(m); in->get_formulas(fmls); fml = mk_and(m, fmls.size(), fmls.c_ptr()); if (m_mode == elim_t) { fml = m.mk_not(fml); } reset(); TRACE("qe", tout << fml << "\n";); if (!hoist(fml)) { result.push_back(in.get()); return; } TRACE("qe", tout << "ex: " << fml << "\n";); lbool is_sat = check_sat(); switch (is_sat) { case l_false: in->reset(); in->inc_depth(); if (m_mode == elim_t) { fml = mk_and(m_answer); } else { fml = m.mk_false(); } in->assert_expr(fml); result.push_back(in.get()); break; case l_true: SASSERT(m_mode == qsat_t); in->reset(); in->inc_depth(); result.push_back(in.get()); if (in->models_enabled()) { model_converter_ref mc; VERIFY(mk_model(mc)); in->add(mc.get()); } break; case l_undef: result.push_back(in.get()); throw tactic_exception("search failed"); } } void collect_statistics(statistics & st) const override { st.copy(m_st); st.update("qsat num rounds", m_stats.m_num_rounds); } void reset_statistics() override { m_stats.reset(); s.m_solver.reset_statistics(); } void cleanup() override { reset(); } void set_logic(symbol const & l) override { } void set_progress_callback(progress_callback * callback) override { } tactic * translate(ast_manager & m) override { return alloc(nlqsat, m, m_mode, m_params); } }; }; tactic * mk_nlqsat_tactic(ast_manager & m, params_ref const& p) { return alloc(qe::nlqsat, m, qe::qsat_t, p); } tactic * mk_nlqe_tactic(ast_manager & m, params_ref const& p) { return alloc(qe::nlqsat, m, qe::elim_t, p); }